DEVELOPING AN ATLAS BASED ON FROND VENATION PATTERNS ANALYSIS OF POLYPODIALES IN TARAKAN

This study aims to identify and analysis of frond venation pattern of Polypodiales in Tarakan, which then developing an atlas based on the results obtained. The results of identify and analysis the frond venation pattern of Polypodiales showed that there were 14 species of Polypodiales. The venation pattern found in Polypodiales were reticulate and open forked. While in the development of an atlas, the assessment result of the content feasibility aspect by the content expert obtained 90.77% (valid), and assessment result of the presentation feasibility aspect obtained 100% (valid). The assessment result of the book size aspect by the media expert obtained 90% (valid), while assessment result of the book cover design aspect obtained 93.33% (valid), and assessment result of the content book design obtained 91.42% (valid). The assessment result of the language usage by language expert obtain 92% (valid), and assessment result of the language accuracy obtained 96% (valid). The field assessment result by lecturer for the easiness aspect obtained 92.31% (valid), the attractiveness aspect obtained 100% (valid), and the understandable aspect obtained 90% (valid). Meanwhile, the field assessment result by student for the easiness aspect obtained 97.43% (valid), the attractiveness aspect obtained 93.33% (valid), and the understandable aspect obtained 100% (valid).


INTRODUCTION
Fern (Pterydophyta) is one of the plant divisions that is spreaded in the world, especially in the tropics (Oloyede, 2012).Ferns are important component for the ecosystem, especially in tropical rain forest areas (Zhang et al., 2014).Ferns are also an important terrestrial plant first thought to have emerged 400 million years ago (Haou et al., 2011).Ferns (Pterydophyta) are group of plants which have the greatest diversity (Vasco et al., 2013).This been estimated that there are approximately 20.000 species, with 225 genera (genus) of ferns around the world (Prosea. 2003within Aminasih et al., 2013;Prastyo et al., 2015), in which the 4,000 species of them exist in Indonesia, Philippines, Papua New Guinea, and northern Australia (Whitten andWhitten. 1995 within Aminasih et al. 2013).In addition, the 3,000 species of those 4,000 ferns are distributed in Indonesia (Loveless, 1995within Jannah et al. 2015).
Fern is a plant that has a lot of diversity in Indonesia (Arini and Kinho, 2012).One of the ordo which has high diversity is Polypodiales.Smith et al. (2006) stated that the Polypodiales ordo on fern has 15 families, including: Polypodiaceae, Davalliaceae, Oleandraceae, Tectariaceae, Lamariopsidaceae, Dryopteridaceae, Onocleaceae, Blechnaceae, Thelypteridaceae, Woodsiaceae, Aspleniaceae, Dennstaedtiaceae, Saccolomataceae, and Lindsaeaceae.Sujalu (2007) found that there were 88.89% of epiphytic ferns in Malinau Research Forest which were belong to Polypodiales group.Similarly, Supu and Munir (2009) also revealed that as much as 81.82% of ephypitic plant in the forest around Lake Lawulamoni in Kabawo Region were Polypodiales.Another research conducted by Dewa et al. (2012) about inventory and characterization of ferns in Bukit Sebubus Tourism Area in West Kalimantan noted that there were 50% of ferns were Polypodiales, which is in line with Arini and Kinho (2012) who found that approximately 81.82% of ferns in Gunung Ambang Conservation Area were Polypodiales.
Polypodiales are characterized by various venations which differentiate each other.Venation patterns are one of the biometric feature of plants (Satyanuraga, 2015;Wahyumianto et al., 2012).The venation pattern similarity indicates genetic relationship among ferns species (Satyanuraga, 2015).In addition, the frond venation patterns in fern also show its evolutionary characteristic (Vasco et al., 2013).
The research results of venation pattern can be developed to be learning media to provide additional knowledge to students, especially in fern identification.The initial observation on students who have taken Plant Morphology and Plant Taxonomy class expeienced problem in their texbooks which are less contextual and pictures on the textbooks only consist of illustrations rather than real pictures.Observation and interview on those students showed that there were about 89.8% of students required more contextual teaching media that also contained many real pictures.
Based on observation and student interview, one of the media that can be developed is atlas.Atlas contains pictures of the elements of information which is selected and described deeper and more detailed for a specific purpose (Nurdin, 2015).The selection of atlas learning in the development of research results is because the atlas is one of the learning materials that emphasizes on the graphic aspect, easy to used as a reference in identification.Graphics aspects in atlas also can increase the student motivation in learning.Tutut (2016) state that the purpose of using atlas is to improve conceptual understanding of the user based on the material and description aspect in detail.Research related to the developing of atlas has been done by Solikhah (2015), it showed that the development of the atlas as a learning media obtained chi-square values for peer reviewers and practitioners of 44.6 and 36.5 with good criteria.
Therefore, it is important to produce an atlas that can help students studyplant morphology and plant taxonomy easily.This atlas is expected to be supporting learning media that can provide contextual data so that students are able to do field identification.

METHOD
This is research and development study.The development model in this research and development used modified development Four-D model based on Thiagarajan et al. (1974).This model consisted of four stages of development, that consist of: define, design develop, and disseminate.In this research and development, the development model was only until the stage of development (develop).
This research consisted of two stages.The first stage was the research stage, consist of: inventory and identification of ferns of Polypodiales ordo and conducting venation pattern analysis.The second stage was the stage of developing the research results into Atlas Learning.

Research Stage
The research stage in this research consisted of two parts, namely: 1) inventory and identification; 2) venation pattern analysis.

Inventory and Identification
Inventory of ferns was done by exploration refering to Hartini within Nasari (2012).Exploration means investigating the whole location, that represent the ecosystem and vegetation types of research area.There are 4 locations for this research that consist of conservation forest in Tarakan (Amal Forest, Gunung Belah Forest, Research Forest of Borneo Tarakan University and Juata Conservation Forest).
The sample was selected based on purposive sampling (Lubis, 2009).The samples were collected based on the existence of ferns which considered the represent area.When one species found more than one, it wouldn't be collected because it has represented the ferns that has been found.
The next step was making herbariums.The herbarium making was aimed to preserve the fern, so it would be easier to observe the characteristics of the ferns.The herbarium making referred to the procedure by Storrie (2009), Victor et al (2004) and Greening Australia (2012).The identification of the species of ferns referred to Sporne (1962), Piggot (1998), Kinho (2009), Tjitrosoepomo (2008) and Stenis (2008).

Venation Pattern Analysis
Venation pattern analysis on ferns referred to Ash et al, (1999), Hoshizaki and Moran (2001) and Simpson (2010).The observation of the venation pattern could be done by using stereo microscope to get detail picture of venation pattern of each frond in ferns.

Development Stage
The development stage in this research consisted of defining stage, designing stage; and developing stage.

Defining Stage
Defining stage is the stage for establishing and defining the requirements of the learning.The defining stage included five main steps, namely: front-end analysis, learner analysis, task analysis, concept analysis and specifying instructional objectives.The details of each step in the define stage are presented in Table 1.

Designing Stage
The designing stage aimed to design learning materials.This stage consists of 4 steps, namely: 1) criterion-test construction; 2) media selection; 3) format selection, which examines the formats of the existing learning materials and determining the formats of learning materials to be developed; 4) making the initial design according to the formats determined.The details of each step in the designing stage are shown in Table 2.

Developing Stage
The developing stage is the stage to develop product, consists of 2 steps, namely: a) expert appraisal followed by the revision; b) developmental testing.The detail of each step in the development stage are shown in Table 3.
There are two data types in this research, namely: research data and product assessment data.The research data is qualitative data about the venation patterns of Polypodiales.The data were then developed into atlas.The product assessment data include quantitative and qualitative data.The quantitative data include the assessment from the validators and students, while the qualitative data are responses and suggestions from the validators and students.
The data of plant species and frond venation have been collected through taking notes of fern patterns and documenting the fern patterns (morphological characteristics on frond venation).Furthermore, the validation of the media has been done by expert validator on several aspects using a questionnaire that consist of aspects presented in Table 4.
The developmental testing (field test) has been done by practitioners and students on several aspect using questionnaire that consists of aspect presented in Table 5.In the validation questionnaire, the questionnaire used Likert scale with alternative options 1-5.The validation questionnaire was used to analyze the quantitative data by calculating the answer percentage.Thus, the percentages were computed by employing equation ( 1).The criteria of validity of the validator assessment was determined based on percentage criteria in Table 4.

Venation Pattern Analysis
The results of the research related to the inventory, identification and venation pattern analysis of ferns found are presented based on Table 7.
The ferns that has been found then grouped based on Polypodiales and the others.The result shows that there are 14 species of Polypodiales.The ferns found are grouped based on families that is included in polypodiales ordo and outside polypodiales ordo.Based on the results of the ferns collected, there are 14 species of ferns belonging to the families of polypodiales.
The data shows that families Aspleniaceae, Blechnaceae, Davalliaceae and Lomariopsidaceae have no variation on their venation pattern.
Open-forked Pteris vitata L. Open-forked The venation variations on these families (Polypodiaceae and Pteridaceae), show the useful characteristic for identification (Figure 1 and 2).For example, the venation pattern of Polypodiaceae on Drymoglossum, and Drynaria is reticulate, while the venation of Dryopteris is open-forked.In Pyrrosia, the venation can not be determined.Probably, it is caused by the pattern that is too thin.For example, the venation patterm of Pteridaceae on Acrosticum is reticulate, while the venation of Pteris, Adiantum and Pityrogramma is open-forked.
The classification of ferns family has been done based on Smith et al. (2006).Some research on fern classification also been done by Christenhusz et al., (2010).He found that the genus of Dryopteris on ordo Polypodiaceae considered as separated family, which is Dryopteridaceae.The genus Nephrolepis is also considered as the family of Nephrolepidaceae.This research is using Smith et al classification because this classification is widely used by researchers on fern study.According to Christenhusz et al., (2010) classification however, variation of frond venation only found in Pteridaceae, while in polypodiaceae there are no variation.
Generally, frond venation on fern can be used in classification and identification process.Most of ferns have pinnate venation form, with central vein then becomes veinlets on each sides.There are few of ferns that have palmate venation.Palmate venation is a venation that has many central veins that come up from the frond base.However, the most important thing on the venation form of ferns is the vein patterns (the smallest vein) or vein segment.There are two kinds of venations ased on the general pattern, which are opened venation and closed venation.The opened venation pattern is the pattern that the veinlets from the central vein are not connected each other.This type of venation consists of two types, which are simple and open-forked.Furthermore, the reticulate (closed venation) is the pattern that its veinlets from central vein connect and become nett-like (Simpson, 2010).

Developing of Atlas
The defining stage on front end analysis has been found that students experienced difficulties in understanding plant species, especially ferns.This is because of the lack contextual of textbooks that they use.On the stage on learner analysis, interviewed on some students found that about 89.8% of 40 sudents needed contextual learning media that consists of many real pictures.
Furthermore, the result of front end analysis then can be arranged to be competence standard and basic competencies.The standard competences that should be achieved in learning are: understanding the principles of analyzing the vanation patterns ferns.Basic Competencies to be achieved are: 1. Describing the types of venation patterns of ferns

Distinguishing venation patterns on different types of fern
Furthermore, the result of concept anaysis then becomes tasks on the learning media that will be developed on the task analysis.Tasks on this media are designed as independent tasks such as field study related to the introduction of ferns.
The next step is specifying instructional objectives that have been arranged based on concept analysis dan task analysis.On this step, the learning instructional has been made as follow: 1. Students are able to explain the types of venation patterns of ferns through proper discussion and literature study 2. Students are able to distinguish the venation pattern of at least 10 leaf types through field observation sheet On the designing stage, each task are designed to be placed at the end of the chapter and has been arranged based on standard competencies and basic competencies, indicators, and learning objectives.According to some considerations on defining stage, then visual media on the form of atlas has been selected as a learning media that is aimed to provide detail visualization on plant morphology through fern pictures on Tarakan for students.The atlas that has been made consists of introduction (basic materials), main materials that consist of fern pictures of Tarakan, and the closing part.
Developing the atlas requires validation and field test to make sure the quality of product.Validation includes: validation by material expert, media expert, and language expert.Field tests include practitioner (lecture) and students.Briefly, the quality of atlas learning is presented in Table 8.
The assessment result of the feasibility content, by material expert, was 90.77% (valid); while the presentation feasibility aspect achieved 100% (valid).The content expert stated that the atlas is very good and has no mistake on the material.It consists of basic material that is related to venation patterns, while the core material consists of the research results of the ferns venation (Figure 3 and 4).Assessment from language expert on language usage aspect obtained 92% (valid) and the language accuracy obtained 96% (valid).Therefore, the language for this atlas is very accurate.
Assessment result of book size aspect by media expert obtained 90% (valid), assessment result of book cover design obtained 93.33% (valid), and assessment result of book content design obtained 91.42% (valid).The composition of the atlas cover consist of fern image from the research (Figure 3).The composition of the atlas content consist of fern images with details explanation fern parts.(figure 4).
The expert validation stage has very important role in developing learning atlas because it consists of the whole quality of learning media content.Learning atlas as one of learning media shoud be validated thoroughly.
According to Depdiknas (2006), learning media is a set of materials/ content that has been arranged systematically, either written or not, in order to achieve condusive learning environmental for learners.This can be related to stages on learning media selection, which are: a) learning materials should support in achieving standard competencies and basic competencies, b) aspects identification on standart competencies and basic competencies, c) identification of learning materials, d) selecting relevant materials to the standard competencies and basic competencies, and e) selecting learning sources.Field assessment result from practitioner on easiness aspect obtained 97.43% (valid), attractiveness aspect obtained 100% (valid) and understanding aspect obtained 90% (valid).On the other hand, field assessment result from students on easiness aspect obtained 97.43% (valid), attractiveness aspect obtained 93.33% (valid) and understanding aspect obtained 100% (valid).Based on inputs and suggestions, it is found that students prefer atlas because it emphasizes on the visual elements, so that students can more easily understand the material.
Finally, the field test has been done to obtain direct responses, reaction, student comments, and practitioners on the learning media that has been developed.Thiagarajan, et al., (1974) says that field test, revision, and refield test should be done to achieve consistent and effective learning media to use.

CONCLUSION
Based on the result and discussion, it can be concluded that: (1) there were 14 species of ferns belonging to the families of Polypodiales ordo.The venation pattern of ferns found is reticulate and open forked.(2) The venation pattern found in Polypodiales were reticulate and open forked.The assessment result of the content feasibility aspect by the content expert obtained 90.77% (valid), and assessment result of the presentation feasibility aspect obtained 100% (valid).The assessment result of the book size aspect by the media expert obtained 90% (valid), while assessment result of the book cover design aspect obtained 93.33% (valid), and assessment result of the content book design obtained 91.42% (valid).The assessment result of the language usage by language expert obtain 92% (valid), and assessment result of the language accuracy obtained 96% (valid).The field assessment result by lecturer for the easiness aspect obtained 92.31% (valid), the attractiveness aspect obtained 100% (valid), and the understandable aspect obtained 90% (valid).Meanwhile, the field assessment result by student for the easiness aspect obtained 97.43% (valid), the attractiveness aspect obtained 93.33% (valid), and the understandable aspect obtained 100% (valid).
The developing learning media in every research is very important to be implemented.The learning media will have a contribution to teaching and learning in classroom.The abundance of local potential in every region in Indonesia can be developed into a learning material in all levels of education.
Further research that can be done is finding out the effectivity of the learning atlas on the improvement of student learning achievement in the teaching and learning process.

REFERENCES
number of respondents in 1 item = ideal score in the item 100% = constan(Arikunto, 2002)

Table 1 .
Details of the steps on the defining stage Stage Description a. Front End Analysis Identifying students problem, especially on the academic aspects related to the material about the venation patterns and the classification of ferns b.Learner Analysis Measuring the students basic knowledge with tests, interviews and questionnaires c.Concept analysisThe standard competences to be achieved in learning are: -Understanding the principles of analyzing the vanation patterns ferns Basic Competencies to be achieved are -Describing the types of venation patterns of ferns -Distinguishing venation patterns on different types of fern d.Task Analysis Tasks include structured tasks on the identification of venation patterns in plants and genetic relationship analysis based on venation patterns e. Specifying instructional objectives The instructional objectives are -Students are able to explain the types of venation patterns of ferns through proper discussion and literature study -Students are able to distinguish the venation pattern of at least 10 leaf types through field observation sheet

Table 2 .
Details of the steps in the designing stage Stage Description a. criterion test construction The task in the atlas are placed at the end of each chapter b. media selection Atlas is the product of this research c. format selection The atlas content consist of: the introduction part, the main part and the closing part.d.Initial designThe initial design is the design of all learning materials that must be done before expert appraisal and developmental testing

Table 3 .
Details of the steps in the developing stage Stage Description a. Expert appraisalThe expert appraisal on the learning materials includes: materials, media and language b.Developmental testingThe field developmental testing is carried out to obtain direct feedback in the form of responses, reactions, comments of the students, and practitioners of the learning materials that have been developed.The sample in this stage was 40 students that has taken plant morphology and plant anatomy.Those sample were selected using purposive sampling that is based on student's grades (low, medium, and high).

Table 5 .
Developmental testing aspect

Table 6 .
Criteria percentage of assessment questionnaire

Table 8 .
Quality of Atlas Learning